• Veritons Song Contest was an online contest which took place between 2012 and 2017. A large number of countries around the world were represented in this contest and an incredible diversity in music was shown. You can still check the songs that took part in the 103 editions by accessing the Database.
[ New Messages · Members · Forum Rules · Search · RSS ]

Today's users:

  • Page 1 of 3
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • »
The future of semi-finals system, you decide!
Gera Date: Sunday, 14 Dec 2014, 18:23 | Message # 1

Green Arrow


Legendary Member
Messages: 5289
Offline
As many pointed out already, our current system with semi-finals if we reach 30 participants it's a little tricky, because the semi-finals are usually kinda small. We decided to implement this system more than 20 editions ago when we reached a record of participants and we wanted to see how it will work. Eh, we saw and the results are not oustanding. From REJU voting to a too small number of participants in a semi-final, this system meet several obstacles.

Now, with a constant growing number of participants, we want you to decide what to do next. We spoke about this with several ocassions, but now we are trying to find an optimal solution for a longer period.

Some suggested total elimination of semi-finals and introducing a big final with 30+ songs. Some suggested the increase of minimum number of participants required to 40. Some are fine with the current system.

What's your opinion?



Narcotraficante Date: Sunday, 14 Dec 2014, 18:25 | Message # 2

Emperor of LA


Elite Member
Messages: 662
Offline
i see sense in semi only with 40+

with 15 songs in semi, i have to vote for songs i dont really love/like
VeraOld Date: Sunday, 14 Dec 2014, 18:57 | Message # 3

Hanim al-Maghrib


Silver Member
Messages: 276
Offline
I am fine with current system but the 40 idea is not bad at all  snow
Mike Date: Sunday, 14 Dec 2014, 19:21 | Message # 4

Prince of the Sun


Platinum Member
Messages: 1462
Offline
How about a grand final with 30+ but let's introduce 9 and 11 points too? And if it's 40+ we should have semi-finals.
Sultana Date: Sunday, 14 Dec 2014, 19:58 | Message # 5

Înalta Sultană a României


Platinum Member
Messages: 1002
Offline
I want only one grand final! 15 - 16 songs in SF is boring and has no sense :(
Andrew Date: Sunday, 14 Dec 2014, 20:48 | Message # 6

Mr. Robot


Platinum Member
Messages: 1377
Offline
One grand final, with 3 or 4 days more to vote in it.
Narcotraficante Date: Monday, 15 Dec 2014, 12:15 | Message # 7

Emperor of LA


Elite Member
Messages: 662
Offline
its not take many time to send entry, so i think a week for it too much, may be make it 3 days, and 11 days for voting, so 2 weeks in general
Gera Date: Monday, 15 Dec 2014, 15:20 | Message # 8

Green Arrow


Legendary Member
Messages: 5289
Offline
Citat Andrew ()
One grand final, with 3 or 4 days more to vote in it.


Citat Trece ()
its not take many time to send entry, so i think a week for it too much, may be make it 3 days, and 11 days for voting, so 2 weeks in general


I agree on the extension of voting period but..

People are sending their entries mostly in weekend so if we do a 3 days confirmation period that would mean not too many people confirming, since 80% are sending their entry friday.

We can try a friday-saturday-sunday confirmation period then 11 days of voting :D



Rom@n Date: Monday, 15 Dec 2014, 16:50 | Message # 9

True Emperor of Bulgaria


Silent Shade
Messages: 32
Offline
Well, I like system of semifinals because it would be easier to vote in finals if we will have only 20 songs except 40
Ank Date: Monday, 15 Dec 2014, 17:30 | Message # 10

Time Lady


Mithril Member
Messages: 1578
Offline
I support the idea of semifinals if we have 40+ participants.

Also, if we are to change the schedule, we could try for one edition to have 3-4 days to send the entry, and more days to vote, and see how that goes. If there aren't enough participants or sth else goes wrong, we'll figure it out then.
Lÿgtön Date: Monday, 15 Dec 2014, 17:37 | Message # 11




Silver Member
Messages: 256
Offline
I like too the idea of smaller confirmation period and a bigger voting period if we will have a huge final

if we have 40+ it would be too painful to listen in one run and give points only to 1/4 of them.

so...my opinion - huge final for <40 participants, semi-finals like ESC for >40 participants

So maybe I should get a nine to five
But I don't want to let it go, there's so much more to life
Narcotraficante Date: Monday, 15 Dec 2014, 18:22 | Message # 12

Emperor of LA


Elite Member
Messages: 662
Offline
make confirmation Thursday-Friday-Saturday, Show-LL at Sunday, voting Sunday-Tuesday, results Wednesday

or

Sunday-Monday-Tuesday, Show-LL at Wednesday, voting Wednesday (1st week)-Friday (2nd week), results Saturday
Gera Date: Monday, 15 Dec 2014, 22:43 | Message # 13

Green Arrow


Legendary Member
Messages: 5289
Offline
Citat Trece ()
make confirmation Thursday-Friday-Saturday, Show-LL at Sunday, voting Sunday-Tuesday, results Wednesday

or

Sunday-Monday-Tuesday, Show-LL at Wednesday, voting Wednesday (1st week)-Friday (2nd week), results Saturday


that moment when both options are attractive rofl hmmmmm...



Vanessa Date: Tuesday, 16 Dec 2014, 17:22 | Message # 14




Lurker
Messages: 7
Offline
Citat Trece ()
Sunday-Monday-Tuesday, Show-LL at Wednesday, voting Wednesday (1st week)-Friday (2nd week), results Saturday
 I think this one is the best option.
Adel97 Date: Wednesday, 17 Dec 2014, 15:26 | Message # 15

Dróttning of Sverige


Elite Member
Messages: 723
Offline
Citat Trece ()
Sunday-Monday-Tuesday, Show-LL at Wednesday, voting Wednesday (1st week)-Friday (2nd week), results Saturday


+1
  • Page 1 of 3
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • »
Search: